Two Systems to Evaluate a Stock's Value

By J. Royden Ward, Chief Analyst, Cabot Benjamin Graham Value Investor
From Cabot Wealth Advisory 2/15/10 Sign up for free Cabot Wealth Advisory e-newsletter

Here's my definition of fundamental analysis as a value investor: Fundamental analysis is any method to evaluate the prospects of a company and/or its stock by analyzing the qualitative and quantitative factors of the company.

There are hundreds of ways to determine whether a stock is undervalued or not. Some methods always work well, while other methods work for only a short time. Some methods are complicated, but others are simple.

I have been using a couple of simple value investing systems during the past 25 years that really work well. The first system is designed to find undervalued growth stocks, and the second system is designed to find bargain-priced value stocks. I call the first system the PEG (price/earnings to growth) ratio and the second the Benjamin Graham system.

The PEG Ratio

Twenty-five years ago, Standard & Poor's created the PEG ratio to measure the degree to which a growth stock is undervalued. I use the ratio to find high-quality growth stocks selling at reasonable prices. The PEG ratio is calculated by dividing the price to earnings (P/E) ratio by the earnings growth rate. The price used in the P/E ratio is the stock's most recent closing price.

Earnings consist of estimated earnings per share (EPS) for the next 12 months. The growth rate (the "G" in the PEG ratio) is the estimated rate of EPS growth for the next five years. A PEG ratio of less than 1.00 indicates that a stock is undervalued. The lowest PEG ratios are best.

In addition to a low PEG ratio, I look for good quality companies with a history of steady earnings and dividends growth. Quality companies may not be extreme bargains, but high-quality companies will likely produce dividend income and price appreciation upon which you can rely.

There is a very simple measure to determine which companies are high-quality and have produced steady earnings and dividend performance during the past five to 10 years. Standard & Poor's evaluates most stocks and assigns a ranking that they call the S&P Quality Ranking.

Companies with A+, A and A- S&P Rankings indicate high quality. I generally like to find companies with these rankings, although I will often include a company with a B+ ranking, if I believe the company has good prospects and a solid balance sheet with little debt.

High-quality stocks with low PEG ratios have consistently outperformed the stock market indexes in advancing and declining markets. Investing in growth stocks at bargain prices makes sense in any stock market environment.

The Benjamin Graham System

I have used one of Benjamin Graham's value investing methods for the past seven years in the Cabot Benjamin Graham Value Investor with great success. The method is based upon minimum price-to-earnings ratios, price-to-book value ratios and measures of quality. The full description of this analysis can be found in Benjamin Graham's book, "The Intelligent Investor."

Mr. Graham suggested that value investors should buy stocks that fit all of the following criteria:
(1)  The current price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio is 9.0 or less.
(2)  The price-to-book value (P/BV) ratio is 1.20 or less.
(3)  The long-term debt-to-current assets ratio is 1.10 or less.
(4)  The current assets-to-current liabilities ratio is 1.50 or more.
(5)  Earnings per share growth during the past five years is 1% or more.
(6)  The company currently pays a dividend.
(7)  The Standard & Poor's Quality Rank is B+ or better.

The list of seven requirements is somewhat long, but several stock screening sites, as well as your favorite broker, can find stocks that meet most or all of them.

Using this analysis, my recommendations have easily beaten the stock market indexes during the past seven years.

Featured Stock Picks

Each write-up features commentary on the picks from one or more of our expert stock market analysts, as well as company details and a stock chart.

More about Value Stocks

Buy low, sell high: it's the oldest trick in the book for a reason. Value stocks can be the safest way to big profits, but how do you find them?


Stock Picks

Tesla Motors

If you’re not on board the stock, there’s no rush. Wait for a better entry point in a more constructive market.

Church

Church & Dwight owns the Arm & Hammer, OxiClean and Trojan brands, as well as some smaller, faster-growing brands. But even after a 35% climb in 18 months, Church & Dwight still looks strong and poised for further gains.

Restoration Hardware

Restoration Hardware (RH) has been on my watch list for a long time. Believe it or not, I’ve been watching the stock for about a year—it was my Top Pick at the 2014 Cabot Investors Conference, nearly one year ago—and now, after a ton of starts and stops, shares look poised to get going.

Cabot Wealth Advisory

Market Shocks (and Aftershocks)

By Paul Goodwin on August 28, 2015

In the stock market, September is usually a time of increased purpose, as the giants of Wall Street return from their summer vacations (after Labor Day), tanned, re-energized and ready to grapple with the market and its challenges.Read More >

My First Market Crash

By Timothy Lutts on August 27, 2015

Everyone remembers their first market crash. Mine was October 19, 1987, when the Dow fell 508 points (22.6%) in one day. This, of course, was before we all had computers on our desks (and in our pockets) to keep us up to date on what was happening. All we had were telephones—and unanswered questions about how some poorly understood computer-trading programs had allowed this to happen.Read More >

Four Ratios and Ratings to Increase Your Returns

By J. Royden Ward on August 25, 2015

My value approach seems contrary to the thinking of most investors, but I believe selling when the market is high and buying when the market is low makes sense. Read More >