Investing Tax Considerations
By Michael Cintolo, Vice President of Investments and Editor of Cabot Market Letter and Cabot Top Ten Report
From Cabot Wealth Advisory 8/7/08 Sign up for free Cabot Wealth Advisory e-newsletter
I want to touch upon one of the big bugaboos with investors—taxes. I regularly talk to subscribers who say something to the effect of, "I can't sell that; I've owned it since 1997 and will have to pay huge taxes if I sell!" And as we approach the end of the year, I inevitably hear "I can take that loss—I have gains to offset anyway."
This is not the correct way to think about taxes. The trick is to think about taxes before you invest...like today, as the stock market builds a bottom to its 2007–08 bear market.
Now, you might be thinking "Thanks Mike...just the thing I want to think about more—taxes." But I began figuring taxes into my thinking a couple of years ago, and it's helped tremendously.
Before you do this, you must make an assumption. You have to believe (really, know) that you're going to make money over time. Not every month, not even every year, but you must have the conviction that you're not going to be carrying losses over for years at a time...like many did post 2000.
With that in your back pocket, you should also know your marginal federal and state tax rates. An average investor in Massachusetts might be paying a 28% Federal rate, plus a sobering 12% short-term capital gains tax to the state.
Translation: 40% of every dollar made in the market (assuming you hold the stock less than a year) goes to the government. To most, this would seem to be a stunning figure...it might even make you want to skip investing altogether. But it's no big deal, as long as you consider the consequences beforehand.
Given the figures above, you should be investing more than you normally would. Stop thinking of a $5,000 profit as a $5,000 profit—it's really a $3,000 profit (assuming a 40% tax rate). And the same goes for losses; a $5,000 loss is really only a $3,000 loss.
Or, said another way, if you double your money in a stock, the reality is actually made much less...because Uncle Sam is going to take 40% (in this example) of that profit. The same goes in the case of a loss, over the long-term, because your losses will be used to offset your gains.
All of this is a way of saying that you really have less money at risk then you think—win or lose, the government is going to take a significant chunk.
Thus, you should be taking taxes into account when investing, and the proper time to do that is before you buy a stock...i.e., when you're deciding how many shares and how much money to invest in the first place.
Disclaimer: I am not a financial advisor or tax consultant (thankfully!), so do your own due diligence when it comes to your tax status. And, of course, the above cannot be taken to extremes—you can't lose all your money, for instance, and then cheerfully say, "Gee, I only lost 60% of it because of tax loss breaks!" That's insane.
As a general rule, you shouldn't risk more than 1% or 2% of your portfolio after taxes, at most, on any single trade. I personally tend to keep my risk around 0.5% or sometimes less.
But my main point is to consider the taxes before you invest—if you do, you'll have a truer grasp of your portfolio.
More Portfolio Management advice:
How to Systematically Assess Your Risk
A "position sheet" will give you a great view of your portfolio's risk and rewards.
How to Handle Stock Losses
Losses are part of the process—it's vital to think of them in the right way.
The Importance of Stop-Losses at Earnings Season
Stocks can rise on hope, but a bad earnings report can do a Hindenburg on an individual stock.
Seven Short Selling Tips
We don't have any official recommendations for short selling, but if you're determined to sell short, here are seven tips.
Investing Tip: On Selling Stocks
Selling a losing stock quickly can prevent you from having to deal with a much larger loss.
The Importance of Having an Investing System
Here are three ways the market is actively trying to take your money and what you can do about it.
Three Changes to Improve Your Investing
A successful small change is much better for you (both financially and emotionally) than a big change that you can't make happen.
Rules to Protect You as the Market Climbs a Wall of Worry
These three rules will help you manage your portfolio.
Year-End Portfolio Review Helps Set Goals for Next Year
Each year end, I review my investing strengths and weaknesses, examining stock charts of previous buys and sells, comparing them to market action, and so on.
How to Watch Your Stocks
Checking your stocks often probably doesn't do any harm, but it does reveal something about you as an investor.
How to Manage Risk during Bear Markets
The secret to surviving the bear market, of course, is adapting.
How to Plan for Stock Investing Risk
Successful investors always consider risk when analyzing their portfolio, adhering to rules like cutting losses short and diversification.
What to Do During Market Corrections
Our advice today, "Just Sit Tight," is little changed from our advice a decade ago.
Investing Basics: Keep your Eye on the Ball
Three rules: follow the market's trend, cut your losses short and let your runners run.
Identify Your Investing System and Stick with It
The hard part, in our experience, is sticking with your investing system.
Growth Stock Investing: Do You Want to Feel Right or Make Money?
Holding on to your losers while selling your winners may make you feel right but the best strategy is to cut your losses short while letting your winners run.
How to Average Up to Buy More of Your Best Stocks
Buying more of your best stocks can be dangerous if misused.
When to Sell Your Winning Stocks
What feels good to most investors is holding on to a big winner...and what feels bad is selling a big winner—but there are times when that's exactly what you should do.
The Importance of Managing Your Portfolio
Both professional and novice investors sometimes forget that the objective is to make money, not to own every good-looking stock in the market.