Growth, Value of Momentum: Match Your Investing System to Your Personality


By Michael Cintolo, Vice President of Investments, Editor of Cabot Market Letter and Cabot Top Ten Report

What's the best system to make money in stocks?

There are no shortages of options to "attack" the market. Value investing was (and is) wildly popular thanks to the media's obsession with Warren Buffett. Some investors favor mutual funds and asset allocation.  Day and swing traders, because of the advent of the Internet, are popular.  Growth investors might be in the momentum camp, the GARP camp (growth at a reasonable price) or the buy-and-hold-forever camp.  And this is just the tip of the iceberg!

Then there are the tactics for portfolio management. Should I buy more on the way down?  When should I sell for a loss? For a profit? How many stocks should I own?  And, oh yeah, how do I decide which stocks to buy!?

Over the years, I’ve executed hundreds of stock trades with my own money, testing various theories and styles, and making plenty of mistakes along the way.

I realized there was no perfect method of investing in stocks. What really matters is matching the system's pros and cons with your own personality. Read that again. It sounds a bit "out there," but I am 100% sure this is true.

I base this not only on my own investing experiences, but also on meeting and corresponding with hundreds of other investors. I've seen solid investors with good discipline and great "market minds" lose boatloads of money because they tried to force themselves into a system they weren't comfortable with—either taking on too much risk, or too little, or owning too few stocks or too many, etc.

Let me give you an example. Say a rather conservative guy was trying an aggressive growth strategy.  Well, as long as his stocks were going up, no problem.  But the market isn't a one-way street, and so when the inevitable correction came around, this investor would be horrified at the quick drawdown (drop from an equity peak) he suffered. And then he'd throw all his rules out the window and sell stocks—usually near a market low.

You might read this and say, "It's obvious why this guy didn't do well. He didn't follow his discipline; he panicked at the bottom!" And that's true. But the fact is you have to have a discipline you truly believe in—one that you can follow without worrying about your financial future when the market gets rough. If you don't believe in the system, you'll never follow your rules when the stress level is high.

Said another way, the more comfortable you feel during periods of adversity, the better the decisions you will make. And that goes hand in hand with better portfolio performance.

More general investing advice
Receive investing tips via email every week. Sign up for our free e-newsletter, Cabot Wealth Advisory.
Cabot Home
Yahoo Finance
Google Finance
Cabot Blog
The Iconoclast Investor is a place for the folks at Cabot to discuss the stock market, investing and relevant news. We want to welcome you to the discussion and encourage you to share your views.
Current Story:
Which Cabot Letter is Right for You?

Traditional growth investors subscribe to our flagship Cabot Market Letter or Cabot Green Investor.

Aggressive investors are comfortable with the high-momentum stocks in Cabot Top Ten Report or the fast-growing foreign stocks in Cabot China & Emerging Markets Report.

Conservative investors follow the Cabot Benjamin Graham Value Letter to invest in high-quality undervalued stocks.

Long term investors find undiscovered emerging companies in Cabot Small-Cap Confidential.

If you're not sure, Cabot Stock of the Month Report will help you build a diversified portfolio of growth, green, momentum, international and value stocks.

 
Market Charts